Apparently, however, this is not what we find. As Neil deGrasse Tyson puts it, most of the universe is not hospitable to life and "so many things in the universe are trying to kill us."
If this is correct, then one could argue as follows:
- Fine-tuning is evidence for God only if the universe is fine-tuned not only for the existence of life but also for the preservation of life.
- Even if the universe is fine-tuned for the existence of life, it is not fine-tuned for the preservation of life.
- Therefore, fine-tuning is not evidence for God.